Is it safe to keep the old furnace running until the new one goes in?
Usually, yes. Most furnaces that are due for replacement still heat the house while you decide, so there is time to get a written price and weigh your options. Two situations are different. If you smell gas, leave the house without switching lights or appliances on or off. Call 911 from outside, then call the gas utility's emergency line. If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, get everyone outside into fresh air and call 911.
The other is a cracked heat exchanger. The heat exchanger keeps combustion gases separate from the air the furnace blows through your rooms, and a crack can let carbon monoxide into that air. If a technician finds one, the furnace is shut off and stays off. In most cases replacing the furnace makes more sense than repairing it. Until then, space heaters can keep the main rooms warm if they're kept clear of curtains and bedding.
The Ontario Fire Code requires a working carbon monoxide alarm next to each sleeping area in a home with a fuel-burning appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage. If your alarms are missing or past their replacement date, replace them before the new furnace arrives.
What signs say it is time to replace rather than repair?
The usual signs are the same part failing again, a repair that costs a large share of a new furnace, or rooms that never warm up on the coldest nights. Others are a furnace that switches on and off constantly, or gas use that keeps rising when nothing else has changed. None of these on its own means the furnace has to go. Each one is a good point to get both prices, the repair and the replacement, and decide with the numbers in front of you. If you're not at that point yet, furnace repair is the place to start.
In Alcona, and on the newer streets of Lefroy and Belle Ewart, many houses built from the 1990s onward got the same builder-installed high-efficiency furnaces. On some streets those furnaces are wearing out at about the same time. If your neighbours are replacing theirs, it makes sense to ask about yours. Still, what decides it is the condition of your own furnace. A failed inducer motor or control board in one house doesn't mean the furnace next door is about to fail.
What changes when the house is an old hamlet home?
Houses from the 1800s in Big Bay Point, Stroud, Belle Ewart and Churchill were built for wood or coal stoves or a gravity furnace. Later they were converted to oil and then to gas. In many of them the ductwork was added afterwards and is smaller than a modern furnace needs, especially if you also want central air. Before choosing a furnace size, the technician looks at the supply runs and the return-air ducts. They'll tell you plainly whether the ducts can carry the air or need work first.
The chimney is the other question. A high-efficiency furnace vents through plastic pipe in the side wall, so it stops using the old masonry chimney. If a gas water heater is still connected to that chimney, it ends up venting alone into a flue built for a much bigger fire. There its exhaust can cool and condense, and it may not draw properly. When that happens, a chimney liner is usually needed. Where it applies, the liner is listed in the written price.
If the water heater might be a rental, check before anything changes. Rental water heaters come from separate rental companies, and replacing one that is still under contract can mean cancellation fees.
How is a new furnace matched to the house and its ducts?
Furnaces in Innisfil work hard. The nearest Environment Canada station, Barrie WPCC, records 4,253.7 heating degree days a year and 12.2 days colder than -20 °C (1981-2010 normals). A furnace here has to keep up through long cold spells. That doesn't mean bigger is better. An oversized furnace heats in short bursts and turns on and off often. It wears out faster and leaves some rooms warmer than others.
Sizing starts with the house: its floor area, insulation, windows, draftiness and which way it faces. Next come the ducts, because a furnace can only deliver as much air as the ducts can carry. In a house with modest ducts, a two-stage or modulating furnace often works better than a single-stage unit of the same output, because it runs longer at a lower speed. If you're also replacing or adding central air, the cooling coil and the furnace fan are chosen together. See air conditioning installation.
A converted cottage with baseboard heat and no ducts may not need a furnace at all. A cold-climate or hybrid heat pump is worth comparing. The guide on which heating system suits your Innisfil house explains the options.
Where will it vent, and how is snow kept off the pipes?
Barrie WPCC averages 223.0 cm of snow a year. The intake and exhaust pipes of a high-efficiency furnace sit low on the side wall, where drifts, snow sliding off the roof and plough banks pile up. If a pipe gets blocked, the furnace shuts itself off as a safety measure. When a new furnace goes in, the technician places the vent ends where the code allows and snow is least likely to bury them, raising them if needed. The vents are also kept the required distance from windows, doors and the gas meter.
A condensing furnace also produces water, which drains away through a condensate line. The line is run and sloped so it won't freeze or back up. If there is no floor drain nearby, a condensate pump is added. Once the furnace is in, clear the pipes outside after each storm and don't store anything against them.
How does a replacement go, from first visit to first heat?
A technician visits to look at the house, the ducts, the venting and the gas line, and asks how the rooms feel through the year. You then get a written price that lists the furnace, the venting, any work on the ducts, chimney liner or drain, and removal of the old furnace. Nothing is installed until you approve it.
In Ontario, gas appliances must be installed by a contractor registered with the Technical Standards and Safety Authority, using certified gas technicians and following the CSA B149.1 Natural Gas and Propane Installation Code; at Innisfil Heating Cooling, work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians. The guide on who is allowed to do gas work explains the rules.
On installation day, the old furnace is disconnected and taken out. The new one is put in place and connected to the gas line, ducts, venting and drain. It is then started, run through full heating cycles and checked for safe burning and correct gas pressure. You're shown the filter, the furnace switch and the vent pipes outside. Register the furnace with its manufacturer within the time it allows. Many manufacturer warranties depend on registration, professional installation and regular servicing. A yearly maintenance visit keeps the drain, vents and filter in good order.
